| October 7
2001 BRITAIN
Banned transplants
from piglets 'cure' teenagers of diabetes
Jonathan Leake and Steve
Leahy
TWO diabetic children
have been freed from a regime of insulin injections with the world's
first transplantation of cells from the testes and pancreas of newborn
piglets.
It could be a breakthrough
in xenotransplantation - replacing human tissues with animal equivalents
- which is banned in many countries, including Britain and America.
Twelve diabetics aged 10 to 15 in Mexico were given pig cells. Two
seemed to recover fully, three reduced their insulin requirements
by more than 40% and the rest improved slightly.
Researchers say a combination
of tissues from specially bred pigs prevented the need for the dangerous
drugs which are required for years after most transplants to stop
the recipient's immune system rejecting foreign cells.
There was controversy
as Dr Rafael Valdes gave his results at last week's International
Xenotransplantation Association congress in Chicago. He said the
"cured" girls, aged 14 and 15, had been injecting insulin
two or three times a day: "It was like they got their childhoods
back."
Although some called
it a breakthrough, others said not enough was known of the risks,
especially of pig viruses spreading into the general population,
one reason why xenotransplantation is widely banned. But Valdes,
who worked at the Children's Hospital of Mexico, says diabetes is
so serious the risks are worthwhile.
He said: "This could
be a breakthrough for millions. In Mexico [diabetes] is the first
cause of blindness and kidney failure. Its impact is worse than
cancer."
In the UK around 1.4m
people are known to have diabetes, and up to 1m may be undiagnosed.
The disease costs the NHS £5.2 billion a year - 9% of its
budget.
Diabetics' blood sugar
levels are too high because the pancreas does not produce enough
active insulin, a glucose-controlling hormone. In Type I or juvenile
diabetes the immune system attacks insulin-producing cells. In Type
II, which affects older people, insulin loses its ability to control
glucose levels.
Dr Robert Elliott, medical
director of the diabetes researchers Diatranz and former child health
professor at the University of Auckland, said: "It's a very
exciting breakthrough."
But Dr David Cooper,
who trained with Christian Barnard, said: "It's too early for
human trials. We need positive, long-term results in animals first."
|